Saturday, April 11, 2015

CURMUDGUCATION: Poor People Don't Have Money

CURMUDGUCATION: Poor People Don't Have Money:

Poor People Don't Have Money









 Poor people don't have money, and that's a problem for the free market. That's a problem, because, well-- don't think of money as a way to buy stuff. Think of money as a way to attract people's attention so they will come give you things or do things for you.


For people with money, the dance is a simple pas de deux between the person with the money and the person with the goods or service. "I see you have money. Let me convince you to give it to me," says the person with the goods. "Make it worth my while to give you my money," says the person with the money. 

It can be a complicated dance at times, but it's relatively straightforward. But the four-cornered dance of the poor is different.

"Make it worth my while to provide this for you," says the person with the goods.

"I can't," says the poor person.

At this point the dance could be over, but in some cases, the government steps in. "To have a smoothly functioning country," says government, "we need to make sure everyone has access to this service." Like food, healthcare, clean water, mail delivery, roads, a standing army.

Sometimes government and corporations do a dance of their own. "I'm going to take the people over here, the ones with money, the ones who can make this worth my while," says the corporation. "You can keep those people over there. The poor ones. The ones we can't make money from." Our mail delivery right now is very much this model. UPS and FedEx and the rest only sort of compete with the United States Postal Service. In fact, when you hire one of the non-USPS companies to deliver a package to East Bumswoggle, Nowherevania, a place so far out that nobody wants to drive on over in search of tiny money, you know who actually delivers it? The USPS, working as a subcontractor for the private corporation. (Fun fact: the USPS has financial problems largely from a Congressional requirement that they pre-fund the retirement of people who don't even work there yet.)


Imagine that a free maket economy consists of taxis, passengers and a government. Passengers attract taxis by standing curbside, waving piles of money. But poor people don't have anything to wave. So the government, either out of altruistic reasons or because they want to get all those poor people off the curb, gets their own batch of taxis to carry the poor home.

Eventually, corporations notice that the government taxis are carrying around big piles of money of their own. And TaxiCorp HQ, somebody says, "That big pile of money has attracted my attention. I wonder how we can get them to give it to us."

Money's a funny thing. When you have a bunch of it, people see you. They acknowledge you. They want to make you happy. But remember-- poor people don't have money. The government has the money.

So the people with the goods and services enter the dance-- but they don't come to dance with the poor folks. They come to dance with the government. This dance can take many forms. (We can make it worth your while to let us do that for you. We can do that better than you.) Or they can bring a fourth party into the dance-- the taxpayers whose money the government collects to pay for things. Look at what those guys are spending your money on! It's wasteful! Go give them hell!

Now there's a weird variation of the dance, because the corporations can mostly only sense money, and poor people don't have any. The machinery needs a way to detect this new kind of resource, a resource that has no money, but which attracts the government's money. If only there were something, some instrument that would both detect the "customers" ripe for plucking and which simultaneously helped make the case that the government needs help.

Voila. Big Standardized Tests.

BS Tests fulfill the function of identifying the market opportunity. BS Test scores tell edupreneurs 
CURMUDGUCATION: Poor People Don't Have Money:

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Hey Spike. Why not name the film, 'ChiRahm'?

Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Hey Spike. Why not name the film, 'ChiRahm'?:



Hey Spike. Why not name the film, 'ChiRahm'?

The city has recorded 355 shootings this year as of Monday compared with 253 shootings for the first quarter of 2014, according to crime statistics released by the Chicago Police Department on Wednesday. Eighty murders were recorded in the first quarter of 2015. There were 62 in the same period last year. -- USA Today
But it was clear that the mayor was none too pleased. If he wants to press the issue, Emanuel could use the Hollywood pipeline provided by his brother, super-agent Ari Emanuel, to make his feelings known to Spike Lee. -- Sun-Times
Yes, Spike Lee is naming his new movie "Chiraq". That is, unless Mayor Rahm Emanuel calls brother Ari, out in Beverly Hills and asks him to pressure Spike otherwise.
Rahm calls Ari: "Hey bro, it's Rahmbo. I need you to put an arm on Spike Lee. He's naming his next film, 'Chirac' and that's going to scare tourists away."
Ari: "I'm on it little brother. He'll change the name or he'll be through in this town. He'll never set foot in Nate & Al's deli again."
Let's see how that works.

The mayor is pissed at Spike. He's afraid the word "Chiraq" will conjure up an unfair image of HIS city. Scare off potential visitors who might mistakenly think Chicago is a city where shootings are up by 40%  and homicides 26%  over a year ago. How silly of them!

He also calls on his pal, Sen. Double D to spread the good news:
“There’s no question that Chicago, as most cities, has its share of Mike Klonsky's SmallTalk Blog: Hey Spike. Why not name the film, 'ChiRahm'?:






Big Education Ape: Special Nite Cap: Catch Up on Today's Post 4/11/15




Special Nite Cap - Catch Up on Today's Post 4/11/15


Special Nite Cap 

CORPORATE ED REFORM



TEACHER TENURE: L.A. TIMES "REPORTER" BLUME CONTINUES TO MANIPULATE HIS READERS - Perdaily.com
TEACHER TENURE: L.A. TIMES "REPORTER" BLUME CONTINUES TO MANIPULATE HIS READERS - Perdaily.com: TEACHER TENURE: L.A. TIMES "REPORTER" BLUME CONTINUES TO MANIPULATE HIS READERS (Mensaje se repite en Español)Los Angeles Times Reporter Howard Blume has had far too much access to the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) and all the other players in public education for far t
ESEA Reauthorization Under Way: Keep the Pressure on Congress! - Living in Dialogue
ESEA Reauthorization Under Way: Keep the Pressure on Congress! - Living in Dialogue: ESEA Reauthorization Under Way: Keep the Pressure on Congress!By Monty Neill and Lisa Guisbond.The draft rewrite of No Child Left Behind that the Senate education committee will debate on April 14 –“Every Child Achieves” (link here)  – fails to reduce the law’s deeply destructive annual testing mandate. It keeps t
Sacramento considers closing after-school programs | Local News - KCRA Home
Sacramento considers closing after-school programs | Local News - KCRA Home: Sacramento considers closing after-school programsCity says programs face declining enrollment, rising costsSHOW TRANSCRIPT SACRAMENTO, Calif. (KCRA) —The Sacramento City Council will vote next Tuesday on a plan to close four of the city's 19 after-school program sites.The city's Parks and Recreation Department, which run
Why Is (Some) Test Cheating Wrong, But “Miracle” School Lies Are OK? | the becoming radical
Why Is (Some) Test Cheating Wrong, But “Miracle” School Lies Are OK? | the becoming radical: WHY IS (SOME) TEST CHEATING WRONG, BUT “MIRACLE” SCHOOL LIES ARE OK? Of course, this all began with a bombshell announcement from the Reagan administration: A Nation at Risk.So it started with a lie.As governor of Texas, George W. Bush, and superintendent of education, Rod Paige, the Texas “miracle” led to
Calderon trial Update: Will Michelle Rhee Testify? | The Sacramento Bee The Sacramento Bee
Kevin de León called as witness in Calderon trial | The Sacramento Bee The Sacramento Bee: Calderon trial Update: Will Michelle Rhee Testify? Kevin de León called as witness in Calderon trialRhee-lated $tory: Michelle Rhee answers Ravitch in New Bookal$o $ee Rhee-lated $tory: Excerpts from "Rhee The Art of the Deal" a new $tory about Corporate Education Reform and the Woman that make$ it
The most important education law is 50 years old, and we're still fighting about it - Vox
The most important education law is 50 years old, and we're still fighting about it - Vox: The most important education law is 50 years old, and we're still fighting about it This sentence from the New York Times might seem straight out of a debate about education in Congress today: "The strings attached to the federal funds were causing many educators to question whether the schools would be
The bill to revise No Child Left Behind is deficient - The Washington Post By Editorial Board
The bill to revise No Child Left Behind is deficient - The Washington Post: The bill to revise No Child Left Behind is deficientA BIPARTISAN senate bill to revise No Child Left Behind preserves annual testing of students as well as the requirement that test scores, broken down by race, income and special needs, be made public. We are glad to see recognition of how critical these much-maligned meas
Atlanta Public School cheating scandal Jurors: 'The evidence piled up' | www.wsbtv.com
APS Jurors: 'The evidence piled up' | www.wsbtv.com: APS Jurors: 'The evidence piled up'Jurors in the Atlanta Public School cheating scandal give their first TV interviewPlease do not miss this as The War Report on Public Education discusses the criminalization of black teachers and the new "school-to-prison pipeline."SUNDAYClick on the website below to listen live and join the discussio
U.S. Students Slide In Global Ranking On Math, Reading, Science : The Two-Way : NPR
U.S. Students Slide In Global Ranking On Math, Reading, Science : The Two-Way : NPR: U.S. Students Slide In Global Ranking On Math, Reading, Science American 15-year-olds continue to turn in flat results in a test that measures students' proficiency in reading, math and science worldwide, failing to crack the global top 20.The Program for International Student Assessment, or PISA, collects test re
Pinpointing Reading Disabilities to Help Students Succeed
Pinpointing Reading Disabilities to Help Students Succeed: Pinpointing Reading Disabilities to Help Students SucceedAPRIL 10, 2015 BY NANCY BAILEY 2 COMMENTSReading disabilities exist. Research in neuroscience is showing this to be true, and public schools and special education should be on the front lines working to remediate these deficits and helping children to adapt so they can be successful
Alliance charters interfering with unionization efforts, complaint says - LA Times
Alliance charters interfering with unionization efforts, complaint says - LA Times: Alliance charters interfering with unionization efforts, complaint says Nearly a month after launching a campaign to unionize the largest charter school group in Los Angeles, some teachers are accusing school leaders of violating state laws that allow educators to organize without fear of reprisal.United Teachers L
Speak to federal legislators about ESEA and get a signed copy of Reign of Error! – The Network For Public Education
Speak to federal legislators about ESEA and get a signed copy of Reign of Error! – The Network For Public Education: Speak to federal legislators about ESEA and get a signed copy of Reign of Error!The advent of the 114th Congress has been marked by renewed energy to reauthorize the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA), better known as No Child Left Behind (NCLB). NCLB, the 2001 reauthoriz
“Opt out now”: The Seattle NAACP revives the legacy W.E.B Du Bois, demands an end to Common Core testing | I AM AN EDUCATOR
“Opt out now”: The Seattle NAACP revives the legacy W.E.B Du Bois, demands an end to Common Core testing | I AM AN EDUCATOR: “Opt out now”: The Seattle NAACP revives the legacy W.E.B Du Bois, demands an end to Common Core testingBy I AM AN EDUCATOR on April 10, 2015“…the Opt Out movement is a vital component of the Black Lives Matter movement and other struggles for social justice in our region. U
Arthur Goldstein: The teacher rating system is a farce - NY Daily News
Arthur Goldstein: The teacher rating system is a farce - NY Daily News: The teacher rating system is a farce: A high-school ESL teacher says he won't change his teaching methods no matter what the governor says Starting in the fall, for the third year in a row, New York City teachers will be judged by a new evaluation system. Gov. Cuomo suggests we don’t want to be evaluated like professionals, bu
Why is Common Core so controversial? Chris Hayes sits down with Arne Duncan
All In with Chris Hayes on msnbc: Why is Common Core so controversial?Why is Common Core so controversial?Chris Hayes sits down with U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and asks him about everything from Common Core to college student debt forgiveness.Duration: 6:52All In with Chris Hayes on msnbc:
DFER-IL Endorses Chicago's Champions of Education - Democrats for Education Reform
DFER-IL Endorses Chicago's Champions of Education - Democrats for Education Reform: Democrats for Education Reform – Illinois (DFER-IL) has made several endorsements for the 2015 municipal elections. The candidates were evaluated on their responses to a questionnaire, as well as their public statements and city council votes.The endorsed candidates are:Alderman JoAnn Thompson (16th)Alderman Thomps
Colorado Teacher—Peggy Robertson—who will REFUSE to give Common Core tests this Spring. | BustED Pencils
Episode 3 - 4/10/15 | BustED Pencils: Colorado Teacher—Peggy Robertson—who will REFUSE to give Common Core tests this Spring.  Episode 3 is here. Trending News exposes the most important issues of the day.  Jed and Tim talk to Colorado Teacher—Peggy Robertson—who will REFUSE to give Common Core tests this Spring.  Poverty rears its ugly head and Matt Damon’s mom dismantles the “poverty can’t be an
Mixing profits and performance at alternative schools | Catalyst Chicago
Mixing profits and performance at alternative schools | Catalyst Chicago: Mixing profits and performance at alternative schools At a conference held by School Board member Deborah Quazzo’s education investment firm Global Silicon Valley Advisors, fellow board member Mahalia Hines introduced Magic Johnson and highlighted Johnson’s visit to a Chicago alternative school that bears his name.Hines said
Education Isn’t the Solution to Income Inequality
Education Isn’t the Solution to Income Inequality: Education Isn’t the Solution to Income Inequality  0 Your Reaction?Source: iStock“[H]igher education may be the surest path to the middle class,” President Obama declared in a 2013 speech on economic mobility. That belief in the power of education lies behind the current administration’s recent efforts to make community college free for students,
Common Schools in a Fractured World - Bloomberg View
Common Schools in a Fractured World - Bloomberg View: Common Schools in a Fractured World “Are we still making citizens?” That’s the title of an important essay by Leon Botstein, president of Bard College, in the spring issue of the journal Democracy. Botstein worries that we nowadays “defend education in purely economic terms, linking education to work and productivity.” Instead, we should embrac
Common Core tests take the imagination out of education | New York Post
Common Core tests take the imagination out of education | New York Post: Common Core tests take the imagination out of education The Common Core was never a good idea.It was a sneaky idea — and sneaky ideas in American public policy tend to have exactly the life span that Common Core has had.The core sneakiness of the Common Core is that it was (and still is) presented as a state-level project whe
California voters take a dim view of teacher tenure - LA Times
California voters take a dim view of teacher tenure - LA Times: California voters take a dim view of teacher tenureGisela Aviles is a 49-year-old real estate agent in Corona. Henry Yoshikawa is a 71-year-old former administrator for a tiny school district in Placer County. And Arianna Rivera is a 23-year-old bank teller in East Los Angeles.Although strikingly different, they are among an overwhelm
Why Has Teacher Morale Plummeted?
Why Has Teacher Morale Plummeted?: Why Has Teacher Morale Plummeted?A slew of policies and technologies promising to dramatically revolutionize teaching and education over the past decade has not only failed to produce desired results, it has also led to a decline in teacher morale, with large numbers leaving the profession.A recent report for the Alliance for Excellent Education, a policy and adv
New York Activists Organize a RoboCall for Opting Out - Living in Dialogue
New York Activists Organize a RoboCall for Opting Out - Living in Dialogue: New York Activists Organize a RoboCall for Opting Out  “It always seems impossible until it is done.” ~Nelson MandelaBy Deb Escobar, Lorri Gumanow, Lisa Kollmer, and Lily Alayne Owen.Refuse the Test Robocall Committee: Katherine Brezler, Deb Escobar, Lorri Gumanow, Lisa Kollmer, and Lily Alayne Owen, along with several oth
Charter schools bill hurts children, helps corporations
Charter schools bill hurts children, helps corporations: Charter schools bill hurts children, helps corporationsThere is a new bill that is being pushed by the Florida House of Representatives aimed at bailing out another group of corporations.However, unlike the banking and auto industry bailouts, this one negatively impacts your children in Lee County. HB 7037 proposes changes in the use of loca
Examining That Proposed Senate ESEA Reauthorization, Part III | deutsch29
Examining That Proposed Senate ESEA Reauthorization, Part III | deutsch29: Examining That Proposed Senate ESEA Reauthorization, Part III This is my third post on contents of the Alexander-Murray, Senate reauthorization draft of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA) scheduled to be presented to the Senate education committee on April 14, 2015.(The first post is here, and the sec
10 Reasons Why NO Child Should Take New York State's Common Core Tests | Alternet
10 Reasons Why NO Child Should Take New York State's Common Core Tests | Alternet: 10 Reasons Why NO Child Should Take New York State's Common Core TestsAdministering these tests is bad pedagogical practice. Dear parents and educators of New York,I teach elementary school in the East New York section of Brooklyn, New York.  In 2013 and 2014, I administered Pearson’s New York State Common Core test

YESTERDAY

Big Education Ape: Special Nite Cap: Catch Up on Today's Post 4/10/15
Special Nite Cap - Catch Up on Today's Post 4/10/15Special Nite Cap CORPORATE ED REFORMLatest Test Security Issue Creates Anxiety for TeachersLatest Test Security Issue Creates Anxiety for Teachers: LATEST TEST SECURITY ISSUE CREATES ANXIETY FOR TEACHERSPlease do not miss this as The War Report on Public Education discusses the criminalization of black teachers and the new "school-to-prison p






2015 National Conference – Chicago

The Countdown to Chicago Has Begun!

The Network For Public Education | 2015 National Conference – Chicago 


LATEST NEWS AND COMMENT FROM EDUCATION

LATEST NEWS AND COMMENT FROM EDUCATION
EduBloggers

Latest News and Comment from Education