Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, November 15, 2011

With Whom do We Stand? A Counterpoint for Education Reform - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher

With Whom do We Stand? A Counterpoint for Education Reform - Living in Dialogue - Education Week Teacher:

With Whom do We Stand? A Counterpoint for Education Reform

Guest post by Steve Silvius and Stephen Danley.

Consider us optimists, but we think the high-stakes test movement has reached its apex and started its decline. It won't happen quickly given the powerful political forces aligned to promote the testing regime, but the test obsessed "accountability" package for education reform won't continue indefinitely. There are too many bad policies (NCLB, Race to the Top), bad performance reports (NAEP, CREDO, last week's Mathematica study), and corruption/cheating/score inflation scandals (ATL, DC, NY, and more). If you need hope, look back at how Diane Ravitch drove an intellectual stake into the heart of the education reform movement on the Daily Show. She asked the audience how they felt about tests. When the crowd booed, Jon Stewart complained that it couldn't be that simple. Tell that to Michelle Rhee now that her reforms have faced the scrutiny of the voting public (in the DC Mayoral race but again this past Tuesday). In a democracy, eventually, the people have their say.

So excuse the optimism; we don't see how this compulsive need to measure something can continue indefinitely